Justia 9
Avvo Rating 10
Avvo Client's Choice Award 2022
Reviews 5 star out of 15 reviews
Leading Lawyers - Celiza P. Braganca
CNBC Badge
Bloomberg Tax
Business Insider
FOX Business
Market Watch
Wealth Management Magazine
Advisor Hub
Financial Advisor IQ
Financial Planning
Investment News
W Radio
Chicago Tribune
PG Pittsburg Gazette

Determining Client Capacity

Bragança Law LLC
old age

The American Bar Association recently published some very helpful guidance for lawyers in considering client capacity to make legal and other decisions. The most important directive is that the correct question is NOT whether a client has capacity — it is whether a client has capacity TO DO A PARTICULAR THING.

Persons with significant cognitive impairments still have the capacity to make certain decisions in their lives. It is important for a lawyer to determine whether a client has the capacity to make decisions about legal matters. This is increasingly important as we serve more aging baby boomer clients.

The ABA notes that “capacity is defined as the ability to perform a task — or make a decision. State laws set out standards of legal capacity for various tasks — to consent to treatment, make a will or deed, make a gift or contract.” A client may have significant cognitive impairments and still have the capacity to make certain important decisions.

The ABA reports that “recent changes have called the legal term “capacity” into question. The U.N. Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities in Article 12 recognizes that “persons with disabilities enjoy legal capacity on an equal basis with others in all aspects of life” and that governments must take measures to assist individuals in exercising their capacity. The emerging principle of supported decision-making focuses on providing the needed support to help people make decisions. Finally, the 2017 Uniform Guardianship, Conservatorship and Other Protective Arrangements Act (UGCOPAA), approved by the Uniform Law Commission for adoption by state legislatures, do not use the term “capacity” – rather, it guides courts in determining whether there is a “basis” for the appointment of a guardian, taking into account needed supports and supported decision-making.”

But, the ABA notes, client capacity is still the touchstone in many statutes and in much case law. Below are the ABA’s 10 commandments of capacity. Check out the description of each of these “commandments” here.

I. Thou shalt presume capacity.

II. Thou shalt talk to the client alone.

III. Thou shalt take steps to maximize client abilities.

IV. Thou shalt not worship anyone standard for capacity.

V. Thou shalt not covet the mini-mental status exam.

VI. Thou shalt not end any query with only the word “capacity.” Yea, the proper query shall be, “Capacity to do What?”

VII. Thou shalt seek the big picture, with all its variability, intermittency, and nuance.

VIII. Thou shalt honor thy client’s own considered or habitual standards of behavior, goals, and values, not those held by you or others.

IX. Thou shalt honor thy client’s confidentiality and autonomy even in the face of incapacity.

X. Thou shalt plan ahead to ensure that one’s wishes are respected.

Client Reviews

Celiza was a great help to me in the course of working to resolve my problem. She was very patient, explaining in detail what was happening and what would follow, doing it in a very professional and friendly...

Barbara M.

As an investor and fiduciary, I have worked with Lisa in several capacities over the last 15 years. Lisa’s diverse background from her tenure as an attorney for the SEC, and in private practice – working on...

Jason M.

Lisa is a strong and tireless advocate. She helped guide me through a complicated investor disclosure issue on a publicly-traded security. Her practical counsel on process--and avoiding unnecessary legal...

Lee B.

Contact Us for a Free Consultation

Fill out the contact form or call us at (847) 906-3460 to schedule your free consultation.

Leave Us a Message